Hospital toilets harbor multi-drug resistant "superbugs", study finds

Trending 2 weeks ago

Pathogenic germs and fungi, including multi-drug resistant "superbugs" person been recovered connected nan floors, ceilings, doorway handles and different surfaces of infirmary toilets successful nan UK, pinch diligent toilets nan worst affected, nan ESCMID Global Congress (formerly ECCMID) successful Barcelona, Spain (27-30 April) will hear.

Women's bathrooms contained less microbes than men's, pinch female unit toilets peculiarly clean, while unisex and abnormal (also unisex) toilets were nan astir contaminated. Multi-drug resistant germs were concentrated successful diligent toilets.

Professor Stephanie Dancer, a advisor microbiologist astatine NHS Lanarkshire, UK wondered whether toilets without lids dispersed microbes to different surfaces successful nan bath erstwhile flushed, arsenic good arsenic whether immoderate toilets are much contaminated than others.

The move to person accepted antheral and female accommodation to unisex accommodation successful immoderate hospitals raises interest that group mightiness beryllium exposed to higher risks of contamination.

For example, manus hygiene surveys show that women are much apt to cleanable their hands aft bath usage than men, truthful we decided to analyse which microbes were coming connected different surfaces successful toilets and really galore of them location were.

Our results look to corroborate what is mostly thought successful society: women cleanable because their cognition of ungraded and disgust entices action whereas men either don't announcement a soiled situation aliases don't care. It follows that women are much apt to time off a bath 'clean', while men presume personification will cleanable up aft them."

Professor Stephanie Dancer, advisor microbiologist astatine NHS Lanarkshire, UK

For nan study, Professor Stephane Dancer and colleagues collected samples from toilets successful 3 wide hospitals successful NHS Lanarkshire.

Ten different surfaces successful six types of toilets were swabbed >4 hours aft cleaning connected 4 different days 1 week isolated successful each hospital.

The surfaces were: hand-touch surfaces (toilet flush; handrail; tap; doorway handle); level surfaces; and precocious sites (door tops; shelves; aerial vents).

The six types of toilets were: antheral staff, female staff, antheral patient, female patient, abnormal and unisex.

480 samples were collected from each infirmary and nan aerobic bioburden (amount of germs and fungi) calculated for each type of surface. Background plants and healthcare pathogens were isolated and identified and antimicrobial susceptibility testing was carried out.

The pathogens detected include: Staphylococcus aureus (which causes coiled and different infections), Escherichia coli, Klebsiella pneumoniae and Enterobacter cloacae (bloodstream and urinary tract infections); Acinetobacter baumannii, Citrobacter and Serrati (bloodstream infections successful compromised patients); Enterococci (urinary tract and coiled infections); Burkholderia cepacia (chest infections successful patients pinch cystic fibrosis); Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Stenotrophomonas maltophilia (chest infections and ventilator-associated pneumonia); Staphylococcus saprophyticus (common origin of urinary tract infections) and Aspergillus fungi (chest infections successful immunocompromised patients).

A important proportionality of isolated pathogens were multidrug-resistant and these organisms were concentrated successful some antheral and female diligent toilets. No MRSA was detected.

Professor Dancer says: "Every type of toilet successful each 3 hospitals receives nan aforesaid cleaning (type and frequency) each time but fixed our findings, we deliberation that diligent toilets should beryllium cleaned much often."

Overall, floors and precocious surfaces yielded higher levels of aerobic germs and fungi than hand-touch sites. It is apt that hand-touch sites are cleaned much thoroughly than different surfaces, says Professor Dancer.

She adds: "In opposition pinch hand-touch sites, floors are a awesome repository of dirt. Anything successful nan aerial yet ends up connected nan floor, on pinch immoderate is brought successful connected people's footwear aliases shed from tegument and apparel erstwhile they usage nan toilet."

To nan researchers' surprise, Gram-negative pathogens specified arsenic E.coli, Stenotrophomonas maltophilia and Klebsiella pneumoniae were arsenic apt to beryllium recovered connected aerial vents, ceilings and nan apical of doors arsenic connected floors.

"We deliberation that nan only logical mentation for this is that toilet flushing aerosolizes immoderate is successful nan toilet bowl, whereupon mini h2o particles carrying these organisms alert up to nan ceiling and contaminate precocious sites," says Professor Dancer.

Female toilets had less microbes than antheral toilets (for example, samples from nan handles wrong nan doors of antheral unit toilets had astir 8 times much microbes than those from nan aforesaid handles successful female unit toilets) and female unit toilets had nan fewest microbes of each toilet types.

This mightiness beryllium owed to much predominant handwashing among females, says Professor Dancer.

Gender-neutral toilets (unisex and disabled) had nan highest microbial load overall. This whitethorn bespeak heavier wide use, arsenic good arsenic different attitudes to cleanliness betwixt men and women, says Professor Dancer. 

Professor Dancer concludes: "Airborne microorganisms and contaminated surfaces transportation a imaginable consequence for infection. Hospital toilets should person lids, which should beryllium closed earlier you flush, and diligent toilets should beryllium cleaned much often than different toilets.

"Single activity and abnormal toilets should beryllium retained; pinch further accommodation branded unisex and disposable for anyone. But based connected this study's findings, I don't judge we should beryllium abandoning azygous activity toilets successful favour of unisex toilets, since these toilets had nan highest microbial load overall."

"None of nan toilets sampled successful nan study had a window. I would beryllium very willing to repetition nan study successful toilets pinch unfastened windows providing an abundant proviso of caller air.

"There is nary uncertainty everyone could do pinch much acquisition connected manus hygiene. The much we each understand astir really to protect ourselves and others from germs, nan better."

She besides advises closing nan toilet lid earlier flushing astatine home.

"Put nan lid down earlier you flush and past lavation your hands good and barren them pinch a cleanable towel," says Professor Dancer.

"If you can, unfastened a model successful nan bathroom, earlier utilizing nan toilet, and that's not conscionable to get free of nan smell."

Similar findings are apt successful different hospitals, depending connected nan type and wave of cleaning and really often they are used, adds Professor Dancer.